What you do is, you reverse image search a gif, then pick one of the unlikely match ups, and do it again!
You might need to alter the search slightly by adding gif to the search box.

I just made a new internet game...

Tex

I just made a new internet game...S

Puppy!

I just made a new internet game...S

Wet cat :/

I just made a new internet game...

Directions?

Dead end. Damn!

Back to the bathcat

I just made a new internet game...S

Twirly girl

I just made a new internet game...S

Wet Floppy...

Bah! Ended again :( Back to twirly lady!

I just made a new internet game...

Bacteria?

I just made a new internet game...

Sparkly!

I just made a new internet game...S

shiney Aries?

I just made a new internet game...

Jack who?

I just made a new internet game...S

Dont tell me, Taylor something?

I just made a new internet game...S

Rihanna is not impressed

I just made a new internet game...S

Woh nice backflip!

I just made a new internet game...



and dead end, unless I want to backtrack to the Miley :/

See if you can do better than 12 in a row :D
And if you end up on Miley make a note, I have a theory that all roads lead Miley.

Edit: Damnit stop messing up my layout!